#maklelan1830 Do not harass or report this creator or comment on their appearance or speech
@maklelanTranscript
I thank you for the comment, but I'm going to argue that you're wrong on three different grounds. The first ground is that the Bible never refers to the Bible because the Bible didn't exist anywhere near the lifetime of anyone who wrote a single word that went into what we now consider the Bible. The New Testament authors do refer to Higrafi, the writings, the scriptures, but in all but one occurrence it is a reference to the Jewish scriptures and it is a reference to an unbounded collection of texts that included a lot more texts than we now consider to be part of the Bible. And other authors in the New Testament cite and quote as authoritative and historical texts that would later be rejected as scripture. For instance, the epistle of Jude directly quotes first enich, which would be rejected in the fourth century. Now there is one text in the New Testament that refers to other texts of the New Testament as scripture. And that second Peter 316, one of the very last texts to be written in the New Testament. Most scholars agree that it was written between around 120 and 150 CE. So the second quarter of the second century CE by that time the writings of Paul had become scripture. And most scholars would say we can also confidently assume that the gospels, the very words of Jesus, had also become scripture by that time period. Now shortly after that a Greek word, Tabivlia, the books, would begin to be used as a synonym for Higrafi, the writings. And this would be used in reference to usually the Jewish scriptures, but sometimes to Christian scripture. We don't have the use of this word in reference to both the Jewish scriptures and the texts of the New Testament together until after the canon had first been authoritatively asserted at the end of the fourth century CE. And this is still being used in the plural, however, the books. It doesn't get used in the singular until it gets borrowed into Latin. So fifth century CE at the very earliest is when we actually have the singular word, the Bible, used in reference to more or less the collection of texts that we now consider to be the Bible. The second reason you're wrong is that there is no part of the Bible that refers to any other part of the Bible as inspired in the sense that we understand it today. That word in Greek would be enthails, and that word does not occur anywhere in the New Testament. Now you're thinking of 2 Timothy 3 16 now, which uses the word "theopnevstokes," which literally means "God breathed." And a lot of people think this means inspired because origin in the third century CE quoted this text dozens of times and argued that it meant the New Testament and the Hebrew Bible were inspired. However, it did not mean that until origin used it to mean that. Prior to that, "theopnevstokes" was used to mean life-giving. And if you would like a full argument for that, there's a book that was published in 2017 by John C. Poirier called "The Invention of the Inspired Text" that goes through all of the data regarding how the word "theopnevstokes" and its different variants was used in early Christianity. Third reason you're wrong is that there is no part of the Bible that refers to any other part of the Bible as the word of God. That phrase was always used to refer to the orally communicated messages that came from God, whether directly or through Jesus or through one of the prophets. And in this time period, they sharply distinguished between orally communicated messages and the written form of those messages. And the orally communicated words of Jesus were considered to have more authority than the written form. This is one of the reasons that Higrafi, the writings, the scriptures of Judaism were considered to be of less authority than the words of Jesus. This is why early Christians talked about the agrafa, the unwritten things, which were things that Jesus communicated orally but that never got written down and they were considered authoritative into the second century as well. So in Mark 7, 13, we have the closest thing to an identification of written texts as the word of God, but it's not quite that. Here's where Jesus says Moses said and then gives a couple of commandments and talks about people disobeying that, making the word of God of no effect. But notice Jesus didn't say it is written. Jesus didn't say Moses wrote. Jesus didn't say the scriptures say. Jesus said Moses said, which refers to an orally communicated message. Now yeah, we can find that message in the written text as well. But again, in this time period, they distinguished between the orally communicated message and the written form of it. So we don't have good evidence that Jesus is actually referring to the written text here. So the word of God would not come to refer to the scriptures until after the texts of the New Testament had been written. And for those three reasons, your assertion is wrong.
Download Transcript
Related Videos

#maklelan1741 Do not harass or report either creator or comment on their appearance or speech

#maklelan1667

#maklelan1796

#maklelan1684 Responding to @4biddenknowledge Shop & @True Geordie (Do not harass or report either creator or comment on their appearance or speech)