0:00 / 0:00

#maklelan1667

@maklelan
271.3K views20.9K likes2:30ENNov 15, 2026
415 words2207 characters15 sentencesReadability: High School

Transcript

I in the Father are one does not mean Jesus as God. Hey everybody, I'm Dan McClellan, I'm a scholar of the Bible and religion. In John 10th 30, Jesus says I in the Father are one and the next verse states that the Jewish folks who are around begin to pick up stones to try to stone him for blasphemy. Now, the argument is that the only reason they would have tried to stone him for blasphemy is if he was claiming to be God. And that's just nonsensical blasphemy included a number of different actions and words that Jesus could have taken that are not only limited to claiming to be God, claiming equality with God, claiming some kind of special relationship with God that all fall short of saying I am God can also obviously qualify. As blasphemy, but there's a more clear reason that I in the Father are one does not mean Jesus as God. What does it mean to be one with the Father? Does it necessarily mean that you are part of the same being a different person within that individual being? Well, we can look in John 17 where Jesus prays three times in the intercessory prayer that his followers become one with him just like he is one with the Father. In other words, whatever this oneness is that Jesus shares with God is communicable and Jesus is explicitly praying or his own followers to achieve oneness with him that is identical to the oneness that he has. With the Father the notion that this oneness means constanciality according to the later developed concept of the Trinity is nonsensical in light of John 17 that would mean that John 17 is suggesting that all of Jesus's followers would become a part of the Trinity. Now, there are folks who are going to argue that the oneness that is being referred to in John 17 is a different type of oneness that Jesus has with God from the oneness that Jesus asserts with God in John 10. And this is very clearly just a rhetorical dodge because there are absolutely no data anywhere that support the notion that when Jesus says I want my followers to be one with me just like I am one with you. That is something different from the oneness that Jesus asserts in John 10. When Jesus says I am one with the Father this does not mean that Jesus says God.